The last week certainly hasn’t quelled my interest in the idea of a protest song. However, if I let the outside world being a huge fucking bummer dictate the content of my blog, The Process Process would fall into a dark, depressing pit from which it would never escape. And who wants that? The song I hope to eventually write may well be one of protest, but before I make that decision, I have many more genres to explore and consider. This week, we’re going to take a look at the oft abused and misunderstood outcast of the musical world: the novelty song.
While weird and funny music has existed since time immemorial, the specific term “novelty song” appears to have originated among the musicians of Tin Pan Alley. It was one of the three subcategories of popular music, with the others being ballads and dance music. Or at least, that’s what Wikipedia says. This sounds like a reasonable origin for the term, but I haven’t found any other sources to corroborate the story, so take this all with a grain of salt.
Generally speaking, novelty songs feature some kind of atypical hook or gimmick. Depending on the song, such gimmicks can include strange instrumentation, humor, bizarre subject matter, or even just funny voices. Really, a novelty song is any song that feels especially novel or unique within the context of an era’s prevailing musical styles. Such a broad definition means that songs that exist within other genres, like love ballads or political anthems, may also be novelty songs. Indeed, my intended combination of clawhammer banjo and operatic baritone will make my song, whatever else it may be, a novelty. (Or at least, it will for the month or two before Baritone Claw becomes the only thing anyone wants to listen to.)
I have to imagine that many musicians have written novelty songs by accident. Something inspires them, and they earnestly create a piece of music that they hope will elicit a pure and equally earnest emotional response. Then people hear some silly lyric about leaving a cake out in the rain and think, “That’s hilarious. I hope someone does a disco cover of this nonsense.”
On the other hand, sometimes people seem hellbent on writing novelty songs only to have audiences accept their work as part of the mainstream. You can’t tell me that Bernie Taupin wrote lines like “Mars ain’t the kind of place to raise your kids/In fact it’s cold as hell/And there’s no one there to raise them if you did,” or “And it seems to me you lived your life like a candle in the wind/never knowing who to cling to when the rain set in” to be taken seriously. These are joke lyrics for joke songs. Bernie Taupin was clearly an aspiring novelty songwriter who made the mistake of partnering with someone so talented that people accepted his insane lyrics without thinking about them. Tragic.
Some songs only become novelties after society has had time to gain perspective. For a brief moment, Shaggy was a mainstream musical act. So was Vanilla Ice. Now, we regard their songs about the denial of blatant infidelity and believing oneself to be a successful rapper as humorous relics of a simpler, dumber time.
The examples from the previous three paragraphs are all valid varieties of music, but my aim is not to follow in any of their footsteps. If I’m going to write a novelty song, I want to do so on purpose and with enough skill that people understand what I’m doing. The artists whose works fall into this category include such luminaries as Weird Al, Tenacious D, Flight of the Conchords, and Roger Miller. By and large, the novel element in these musicians’ catalogs is humor, and in Weird Al’s case, humor and the accordion.
Novelty songs featuring silly voices or dumb lyrics can be fun for a time, but they tend to have a shorter than average shelf life. The very things that make them initially popular also make them annoying in fairly short order. The beauty of comedic novelty is that it isn’t really novelty at all. Well-crafted funny lyrics are still well-crafted lyrics. Paired with good music, they become good songs that also happen to be funny. Weird Al’s “Mission Statement” is both a hilarious send up of corporate jargon and a pitch perfect homage to the musical stylings of Crosby, Stills, and Nash. It is funny AND a great song. That’s the needle I would hope to thread should I go the novelty route.
Truthfully, even if I don’t go full novelty song, I can’t imagine I’ll write something with no jokes at all. I am who I am, and I write how I write. My work should, and inevitably will, reflect that. Genre labels are messy and imperfect, often to the point of uselessness. Frequently, they exist to create arbitrary hierarchies within particular artforms, but the best things often defy clean categorization. Purposefully or not, my song will almost certainly fit the definition of “novelty song.” I’m eager to discover which other definitions it will fit. Maybe disco? Time will tell!
Banjo update: I started clawhammer class on Tuesday, and I’m really enjoying it so far. It feels entirely different from bluegrass style, which is an adjustment, but it also feels natural in my right hand. I’m super excited to keep learning.
Novel update: Last week, I killed a character, and this week, I may have brought another one back from the dead, so my net body count is down to one again. A big piece of the story just fell into place. I can’t wait to see where it goes!
Join me in two weeks as I discover and dedicate my entire being to the genre of Pirate Metal.